Ukraine is offered Donbas in exchange for NATO, but Russia is already demanding Europe itself: Trump’s peace plan faces Kremlin ultimatums

Washington discusses transferring Donbas to Russia in exchange for Ukraine’s NATO membership. Moscow responds with a refusal and demands to limit the alliance’s military presence in Eastern Europe. As a result, negotiations to end the war affect the security of dozens of states that are not willing to give the Kremlin the right to decide their fate.

On November 18, 2026, Bloomberg revealed new details of American negotiations with Kyiv and Moscow. Representatives of Donald Trump were investigating whether Ukraine would agree to cede Donbas in exchange for joining NATO.

At the same time, the Institute for the Study of War (ISW) reported that Russia continues to reject US proposals and returns to the ultimatums of December 2021.

Author: R. Verter

What Zelensky confirmed back on November 14

The American initiative cannot be considered a done deal. However, the very fact of the discussion was confirmed by Volodymyr Zelensky.

On November 14, the Ukrainian president stated that American negotiators proposed considering the withdrawal of Ukrainian troops from Donbas in exchange for the country’s NATO membership.

However, there is no agreement from Kyiv. The legal content of the proposed concession is also undefined: the withdrawal of the army from the territory is not equivalent to recognizing it as Russian.

American negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner resumed intensive contacts after talks in Abu Dhabi and Moscow. Washington is simultaneously discussing ending the war, deploying weapons, and future relations between Russia and NATO.

Why Russia demands a return to 1997

On November 17, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergey Ryabkov called Ukrainian NATO membership “categorically unacceptable” and stated that European participation in further negotiations is not being discussed.

Sergey Lavrov, for his part, opposed attempts by European states to form a new security system without Moscow.

The Kremlin is once again referring to the demands of December 2021: refusal of NATO expansion, restrictions on the alliance’s military activity and missile deployment, as well as additional military presence in countries that joined after 1997.

For the Israeli reader, let’s clarify: in 1997, Russia and NATO signed the Founding Act. Later, Poland, the Czech Republic, Hungary, the Baltic states, Romania, Bulgaria, and then Finland and Sweden joined the alliance.

Moscow wants to limit the deployment of NATO forces on the eastern flank. This does not mean the formal exclusion of the listed states from the alliance, but it could weaken their defense.

In return, according to Bloomberg, Russia allows for the reduction of its troops in the Kaliningrad region and Belarus.

Kaliningrad is a Russian enclave between Poland and Lithuania, an important military foothold in the Baltic. Belarus is an ally of Moscow, from whose territory the invasion of Ukraine began in February 2022.

The scale of the possible Russian reduction is not specified.

Europe fears an agreement behind its back

In closed consultations in Dublin, European leaders discussed the possibility of joining the negotiations to prevent independent agreements between Washington and Moscow.

Germany, France, the UK, Italy, Poland, and EU representatives have identified a group of national security advisors to participate in the process.

The European position: first, the cessation of Russian hostilities, then the discussion of future security rules.

Poland and the Baltic states, directly affected by Russian demands, are particularly concerned. Some European politicians allow for border changes with Kyiv’s consent but do not intend to accept NATO restrictions.

The Kremlin, however, disputes Europe’s very participation in the negotiations.

Why Washington is in a hurry, and Moscow can wait

After the US midterm elections, Trump’s team is eager to achieve results by January 2027, when the new Congress with strengthened Democratic positions will begin work. They may demand additional sanctions against Russia and increased aid to Ukraine.

European diplomats interviewed by Bloomberg suggest that Putin is counting on a winter military campaign and political changes in Europe in 2027, primarily in France.

These assumptions are not proof of his plans.

On November 19, Witkoff and Kushner are scheduled to meet in Berlin with Ukrainian and European representatives to discuss security guarantees and post-war recovery.

What this story means for Israel

Israel is not a NATO member and, unlike its members, is not protected by Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty on collective defense.

But Israel is linked to the US by a strategic military partnership. Therefore, the question of how stable American guarantees are under changing political circumstances is important for Jerusalem.

There is also an Iranian context. European diplomats fear that Trump may exit the Ukrainian negotiations without results, as Bloomberg assesses happened in the Iranian direction. This is a comparison of negotiation approaches, not an identity of the two conflicts.

Why Donbas may not be the last demand

The Kremlin has not abandoned the conditions outlined by Putin in June 2024: the withdrawal of Ukrainian forces from the Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson regions, including areas not controlled by Russia, refusal of NATO, and restrictions on Ukrainian defense sovereignty.

NAnews previously reported on Moscow’s claims to Ukrainian cities not controlled by its army in an article about Kramatorsk and Sloviansk.

It turns out that Washington is discussing a territorial concession in exchange for Ukraine’s NATO membership, Moscow rejects this membership and simultaneously demands changes to security rules for current alliance members.

There is no agreement from Kyiv on territorial concessions. Europeans refuse to accept restrictions on their defense. Russian demands remain unchanged.

It is still unknown which part of the discussed proposals could become the basis of a real agreement.